Insight for Action #10

Trust in Clinicians

Older Adults' Needs

To have trust in their healthcare, older adults need clinicians who take time, communicate clearly, relate to them personally, and respect their autonomy.

Insight for Action

The complex and sometimes insensitive character of healthcare makes older adults value clinicians who validate their experiences and priorities, while enabling their sense of autonomy in decision-making.

Policy Perspectives

The hallmarks of building trust—attentive listening, clear communication, patience, reliability, and cultural competence and concordance—are often not aligned with medical incentives. Instead, the current system prioritizes volume of visits and focuses on administrative reporting. As a result, clinicians lack the time and space to build rapport with older adults seeking medical care. Healthcare professionals should be incentivized to build trust and long-standing, meaningful relationships that can lead to positive health outcomes and downstream cost-effectiveness.1

Policy actions, including reimbursement enhancements, that reward empathetic and engaging primary care should be pursued in the context of broader physician payment and practice reforms. Changes to higher education and medical school—from recruitment and admission practices to curricula—are also needed to increase the numbers and diversity of the workforce trained and practicing in primary care to create a pipeline of healthcare professionals who reflect the identities and experiences of their patients.


1. Carter, Julie. “New Studies on Access to Mental Health and Substance Use Disorder Care Highlight the Need for Parity in Medicare.” Medicare Rights Center, August 24, 2023. https://www.medicarerights.org/medicare-watch/2023/08/24/new-studies-on-access-to-mental-health-and-substance-use-disorder-care-highlight-the-need-for-parity-in-medicare.

Hear from Older Adults

The playlist below compiles videos of older adults and other participants talking about this insight.

Login to view and interact with video clips individually.

Theme #1

There is wariness among people of marginalized identities about discrimination, inequitable care, and mistreatment in healthcare settings.

Theme #2

Many older adults are wary of being overprescribed.

Theme #3

There is a common desire for clinicians who take time to listen and relate personally.

Theme #4

There is a common desire for clinicians who communicate clearly.

Theme #5

Many older adults prioritize clinicians who share their race, culture, gender, language, or faith.

Theme #6

There is a common desire for clinicians who respect an individual's wishes and perspective about their care.

"Daniela" #18

Older Adult
voice_selection
Direct Quote
article
Summary from Transcript
video_camera_front
Video/Audio

She thinks it's important for her providers to see her identities and to listen to her about her health, but she questions if they do. "Oh, I think it's important they should see it all. But do they? I don't know. I go down the hill for my diabetes [and] they give me gabapentin. I said I can't take gabapentin. It makes me jittery.... It takes me back into... my addiction to my dark days. I don't want to go. I don't want to visit them. I don't want to take medicine that wasn't.... I told her about the Metformin and I said, it makes my stomach hurt and it gives me diarrhea and stuff. Yeah. Oh, well just, you know .... Uh, don't, don't take three pills a day, take two a day. And if that don't work, then take one a day and just, you know, take one a day, you know, stuff. Uh, You know, I don't know. It's like a, a general, uh, thing. Once you're, once you're, uh, labeled as a diabetic and, or, or high blood pressure, you know, these things that they say that, are that, are due to our culture and our race and things and our ethnicity of us and stuff, the high, uh, the high part. Uh, of these things, then you just, you, you get category, you get in, you get channel, you know, and, and, and they don't start, they, they look at you as a, uh, facts and statistics."

Health and Well-Being: Chronic Health Conditions and Management, Substance Use; Healthcare: Effects of Medications, Healthcare Experiences; Personal Story and Identity: Cultural Competence, Racism;
Theme #7

Some desire naturopathic care in balance with Western medicine.

"Yuen" #05

Older Adult
voice_selection
Direct Quote
video_camera_front
Video/Audio

"I think combining Western and Chinese medicine is really good in my mind!... From my personal experience and seeing my relatives and friends, those who have passed away and those who have survived, those who were treated successfully and those who weren't. I think that if it's Chinese medicine, it can really condition the body very thoroughly. But.... if it's Chinese medicine, you can only feel the pulse; you can't see what's inside.... So, in this aspect, Western medicine has the capability to write a prescription for you to take an X-ray. So I think combining Western and Chinese medicine can be more helpful for a patient.... Chinese medicine is not covered at all [by health insurance]. Let me tell you an example, like myself, I once let an elderly person sit on my lap.... Because her [house corridor] was quite long, she walked to the washroom's side.... She said, 'I'm dizzy.... Give me a chair to sit on.... Don't put me down! I might have a stroke and die!' That really scared me to death. I was just starting to do care work, so I panicked, I really didn't know what to do.... So I used my knee [and said] 'Granny! Sit on here first!' .... After sitting down, she was fine.... After I left, suddenly, the following week, there was a morning when I couldn't get up.... I went to see the doctor, and the doctor said my knee was inflamed, so they gave me anti-inflammatory medication. I took the medication, but it didn't help. Then my leg swelled up like a pig's trotter. I went to see the doctor, and the doctor said I needed surgery. You know, when I heard the word surgery, I got scared. I didn't want to do it, no matter how serious it was. When I lifted my leg up I cried immediately. It was so painful. Now that I think back, it hurts more than childbirth.... Then I went to the doctor, who gave me a painkiller injection. Then I saw a Chinese medicine doctor, took herbal medicine, and applied traditional Chinese medicinal plasters for more than three months before I recovered and could work again. It was so miserable!"

Health and Well-Being: Health Attitudes & Perception; Healthcare: Holistic Care;
Theme #8

Many see root cause for their dissatisfactions in the consolidation of health systems. Many see root cause for their dissatisfactions in the consolidation of health systems.

Theme #9

What helps?

What Subject-Matter Experts Say

Insight for Action #1

Aspirations for Older Age

Americans need to prepare for older age starting earlier in life to feel secure as older adults. As older adults, they need a feeling of social value to believe in their own agency as well as a sense of purpose to prosper.
arrow_outward
Read More
Insight for Action #2

Social Connection

To feel and be less isolated, older adults need both personal relationships and access to groups or programs at community sites that affirm their values.

arrow_outward
Read More
Insight for Action #3

Caregiver Support

Older adults and their caregivers—whether family members or professionals—need recognition, support, and training regarding receiving and providing care.

arrow_outward
Read More
Insight for Action #4

Transportation Access

Older adults need access to easy, reliable, affordable transportation to retain the mobility that enables independent adulthood.

arrow_outward
Read More
Insight for Action #5

Housing Access & Suitability

To retain their agency, older adults need stable and accessible housing that they can afford, maintain, and physically navigate.

arrow_outward
Read More
Insight for Action #6

Finances for Basic Needs

Older adults receiving income under 400% of the federal poverty line (approximately $60,000 a year for individuals and just over $80,000 for couples in 2024) need assistance covering essential needs to survive on a fixed income without sacrificing their health or well-being.

arrow_outward
Read More
Insight for Action #7

Comprehensive & Seamless Healthcare Coverage

Older adults need affordable healthcare coverage and benefits that support their whole health and well-being.

arrow_outward
Read More
Insight for Action #8

Navigation of Healthcare Benefits & Coverage

To make better coverage decisions, older adults need benefits eligibility, access, and coverage to be more straightforward.

arrow_outward
Read More
Insight for Action #9

Mental Health Services

Older adults need approachable and accessible support for their mental health, to work through new or longstanding clinical conditions.

arrow_outward
Read More
Insight for Action #10

Trust in Clinicians

To have trust in their healthcare, older adults need clinicians who take time, communicate clearly, relate to them personally, and respect their autonomy.

arrow_outward
Read More